Best Books3

Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel

by Lucy Foley
 Cover of Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel by Lucy Foley – a new Miss Marple mystery novel authorized by the Agatha Christie estate, set in a snowbound Swiss Alps hotel

Discussion Questions

Need a quick refresher before your meeting? Read Murder At The Grand Alpine Hotel Book Summary



Behind The Book:
The Agatha Christie Connection

Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel draws on a mystery tradition made famous by Agatha Christie: a limited group of suspects, an isolated setting, hidden motives, and the growing realization that the killer may be someone in the room.

You don't need to be an Agatha Christie reader to enjoy the story. But knowing this connection adds another layer to the discussion: What makes the classic whodunit formula still so much fun for modern readers?
+ Host Icebreakers
Ice Breaker Question:
If you were staying at the Grand Alpine Hotel when the murder happened, would you help Miss Marple investigate—or stay safely in your room?
Historical Trivia:
Which Poirot classic inspired the isolated, blizzard-locked setting of Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel?
+ Answer:
Murder on the Orient Express.
+ Host Tips, Content Warnings
Spoiler Alert:
The discussion questions below contain spoilers and are intended for readers who have finished Murder At The Grand Alpine Hotel. If you haven't finished the book yet, we recommend coming back after you've turned the final page.

Content Warning:
No content warnings noted for Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel.
Book Club Questions By Princeton Book Review
These book club questions explore the suspects, secrets, motives, snowy hotel setting, and the classic Agatha Christie-style mystery at the heart of Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel.

1. Four narrators tell the story, and Miss Marple has no chapter of her own. How did seeing her only through other people's eyes affect your view of her? Did it make her more or less effective as a detective?

2. Each narrator is initially defined by a label, such as "the famous actress" or "the wealthy wife." How did Foley use those labels to shape-or misdirect-your first impressions? Which character turned out to be most different from the person you initially thought they were?

3. How does Miss Marple's portrayal as a harmless older woman impact her ability to gather information and solve mysteries in the story?

4. How well did Foley capture Agatha Christie's classic sleuth's charm? Did Miss Marple stay true to her roots, or did she seem more modern?

5. A railway isolates the hotel, and a blizzard cuts it off. How did the setting add to the tension? Did the hotel seem like a character itself?

6. Which narrator did you trust most, and which did you trust least? Did your opinion change as the story went on?

7. Did you guess the solution before it was revealed? Looking back, which clues did you miss or misread?

8. Where did you notice Foley's style in her closed-circle thrillers like The Guest List and The Hunting Party, and where did the book feel more like a classic Christie?

9. Several characters have reasons to want revenge or believe someone deserves punishment. Did understanding their motives change how you judged their actions?

10. What does the book suggest about whether the past can ever really be left behind?

11.Where does the book draw the line between justice and revenge?

12. Was the final confrontation satisfying and logical? Did Foley leave too many loose ends, or did Miss Marple resolve everything?

+ Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel Read-Alikes
Looking for books like Murder at the Grand Hotel?
Set inside the luxurious Regency Grand Hotel, a meticulous hotel maid named Molly finds a wealthy guest dead in his bed and must navigate the secret underbelly of the staff and guests to clear her name.

Legendary mystery writers like Agatha Christie and Dorothy L. Sayers form a secret society to solve a baffling real-life murder, only to find one of their own targeted by the killer.

A journalist on a luxury small-ship cruise witnesses a woman being thrown overboard in the middle of the night-but all passengers are accounted for, and nobody believes her story.


Book Club Talking Points
Murder at the Alpine Hotel is a great choice for book clubs that enjoy classic mysteries with plenty to discuss. The snowy setting and group of secretive guests give readers plenty of suspects to cheer for-or against. The Agatha Christie connection also makes for interesting conversations about how a modern author can capture the spirit of a classic mystery.



PBR book reviews and Reading guides for book clubs
10 Books I Can't Stop Recommending
Book blog- Immersive reads